click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
supreme court cases
required cases
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| marbury v madison | Scenario: Marbury sued for a withheld government job commission. Constitutional basis: Article 3 (Judiciary) Issue: Established judicial review, allowing the Supreme Court to declare laws unconstitutional. |
| mcculloch v maryland | Scenario: Maryland tried to tax the federal bank; the bank refused to pay. Constitutional basis: Article 1, Section 8 (Necessary and Proper Clause); Article 6 (Supremacy Clause) Issue: Confirmed federal supremacy and upheld Congress’s implied powers. |
| schenck v united states | Scenario: Schenck distributed anti-draft leaflets during WWI and was convicted under the Espionage Act. Constitutional basis: First Amendment (Free Speech Clause) Issue: “clear and present danger” test limiting free speech during wartime. |
| brown v board of ed | Scenario: Black children denied admission to white public schools. Constitutional basis: Fourteenth Amendment (Equal Protection Clause) Issue: Declared racial school segregation unconstitutional, overturning “separate but equal.” |
| baker v carr | Scenario: Tennessee residents challenged unequal legislative redistricting. Constitutional basis: Fourteenth Amendment (Equal Protection Clause) Issue: Established federal courts can review apportionment/redistricting cases (one person, one vote). |
| engel v vitale | Scenario: School required students to recite a prayer. Constitutional basis: First Amendment (Establishment Clause) Issue: Prohibited school-sponsored prayer, enforcing separation of church and state. |
| gideon v wainwright | Scenario: Man was denied a court-appointed lawyer in a felony trial. Constitutional basis: Sixth Amendment (Right to counsel); Fourteenth Amendment (Incorporation) Issue: Guaranteed the right to a lawyer for defendants who cannot afford one. |
| tinker v des moines | Scenario: Students wore black armbands protesting the Vietnam War and were suspended. Constitutional basis: First Amendment (Free Speech Clause) Issue: Protected student free speech rights in public schools. |
| new york times co. v united states | Scenario: Government tried to stop newspapers from publishing classified Pentagon Papers. Constitutional basis: First Amendment (Freedom of the Press) Issue: Upheld freedom of the press against prior restraint. |
| wisconsin v yoder | Scenario: Amish parents refused to send children to school past 8th grade. Constitutional basis: First Amendment (Free Exercise Clause) Issue: Protected religious freedom against compulsory education laws. |
| shaw v reno | Scenario: North Carolina created oddly shaped districts to increase minority representation. Constitutional basis: 14th amendment (Equal Protection Clause) Issue: racial gerrymandering violates equal protection even if intended to help minorities. |
| united states v lopez | Scenario: Student carried a gun to school, challenging federal Gun-Free School Zones Act. Constitutional basis: Article 1, Section 8 (Commerce Clause) Issue: Limited Congress’s power under the commerce clause, ruling the law unconstitutional. |
| mcdonald v chicago | Scenario: Chicago’s handgun ban challenged by a resident. Constitutional basis: Second Amendment (Right to bear arms); Fourteenth Amendment (Incorporation) Issue: Incorporated the Second Amendment to apply to states. |
| citizens united v fec | Scenario: Group wanted to air political ads funded by corporations. Constitutional basis: First Amendment (Free Speech Clause) Issue: Allowed unlimited corporate and union spending in elections as protected free speech. |