click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Evolutionary Biology
Speciation 3
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Causes for speciation | Macro(mutation) Genetic drift Natural selection (a) Directly Reinforcement (b) Indirectly In allopatry In sympatry Sexual selection |
| 1. (Macro)mutation as a cause of speciation | Speciation via polyploidy Polyploidy – doubling of chromosomes either through hybridisation or spontaneous doubling within a species Allopolyploidy = hybridisation Autopolyploidy = Same species doubling |
| 1. (Macro)mutation as a cause of speciation | Estimated 30-70 % plants are polyploids Also occurs in animals – e.g. salmonids, cyprinids, catfish…. i.e. Speciation by polyploidy in plants e.g. Goatsbeards (Tragopogon spp) in N. America |
| 2. Genetic drift as a cause of speciation | Proposed to occur under peripatric mode Also known as founder effect speciation (Mayr) |
| 2. Genetic drift as a cause of speciation | A small subpopulation becomes geographically isolated from parent population, and becomes reproductively incompatible through genetic drift Reproductive incompatibility may also be aided by indirect effects of natural selection |
| Example of speciation by genetic drift via peripatric mode | Hawaiian drosophila New species vary across island habitats |
| Evidence for founder effect, speciation via genetic drift | Bottlenecking experiments in Drosophila (experiment separating putative effects of genetic drift from those of natural selection) |
| Evidence for founder effect, speciation via genetic drift | Rundle passed >40 experimental Drosophila populations through bottlenecks In mating experiments, no significant sexual isolation from parent population |
| 3. Natural selection as a cause of speciation | Natural selection as a direct cause of speciation (reinforcement) Reinforcement = selection for prezygotic isolation, arising from reduced fitness in hybrids |
| (b) Natural selection as an indirect cause of speciation: | Populations adapt to different environments or niches (in (i) allopatry or (ii) sympatry), reproductive isolation follows as a by-product |
| Speciation in the laboratory 1 e.g. Fruitfly Drosophila pseudoobscura (Dodd 1989 Evolution) | 8 populations: 4 reared on starch-based medium 4 reared on maltose-based medium Result = positive assortative mating: individuals from each group prefer to mate with opposite sex from same group, even across cages |
| 3. Natural selection as a cause of speciation | (b) Natural selection as an indirect cause of speciation: (i, ii) In sympatry (within lakes) / allopatry (between lakes): Ecological character displacement within lakes (natural selection for habitat specialisation): |
| ‘Ecological character displacement’ | Competition (e.g. for food) between diverging species may be important in driving adaptive radiation (i.e. a series of rapid speciation events) |
| ‘Ecological character displacement’ | Evidence that competition is important comes from a number of studies supporting the idea of ‘ecological character displacement': i.e. the influence of one species on the evolution of another as aconsequence of competition for resources |
| ‘Ecological character displacement’ | The idea is that (i) competition (e.g. for food) plays a critical role in divergence and that (ii) character displacement occurs following competition for similar ecological niches |
| (b) Natural selection as an indirect cause of speciation: (ii) In sympatry: | e.g. Host race formation in phytophagous (plant-eating) insects: case of the Apple Maggot Fly (Rhagoletis pomonella) in N. America |
| (b) Natural selection as an indirect cause of speciation: (ii) In sympatry: | Indirect natural selection (associated with specialisation on different host plants) has caused speciation to occur sympatrically |
| 4. Sexual selection as a cause of speciation e.g. Cichlid Fish species flocks of the African Great Lakes | Features predisposing cichlid fish to adaptive radiation 1) feeding biology (pharyngeal jaw) 2) reproductive biology |
| Three stages in speciation of African Great Lake cichlids | 1) Habitat choice (water column, rock, sand) 2) Ecological diversification 3) Colour diversification through sexual selection (via female choice of male colour differences) |
| Evidence for microallopatry in Great Lake Cichlids | Geological evidence shows water levels have fallen and risen, so lakes may have been formerly subdivided Few species have lake-wide distributions |
| Evidence for sexual selection causing speciation in African cichlids | If sexual selection has driven speciation, expect allopatric, related colour forms (putative incipient species) to show assortative mating |
| Summary | Evolutionary causes of speciation include macromutation (polyploidy), genetic drift, natural selection (directly, indirectly) and sexual selection These processes are not mutually exclusive and may act in combination |
| Summary | In most cases of speciation, including some well-studied ones, the mode and/or cause of speciation remain unknown and/or uncertain Indirect natural selection can cause speciation in sympatry (as well as in allopatry) |
| Summary | Host race formation in phytophagous insects is probably a major precursor to sympatric speciation as a result of indirect natural selection The Cichlid fish of the African Great Lakes demonstrate extraordinarily rapid and prolific speciation |
| Summary | This probably involved a mixture of indirect natural selection (ecological selection) and sexual selection operating in allopatry |