click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Criminal Law - GenD
General Defences: Automatism
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Test for automatism | Total loss of voluntary control due to an external factor |
| Smallshire | Automatism is "a complete loss of voluntary control that is not caused by what the person could reasonably foresee and is not a self-induced incapacity or one that was a result of a disease of the mind" |
| Quick | Takes insulin (external factor) and goes into a hypoglycaemic state (loss of control) - Defence applied |
| T | D suffered PTSD from rape and carried out a robbery. Rape is an external factor, but still formed MR during robbery so no defence |
| AG Ref No.2 of 1992 | Lorry driver drifting in and out of sleep hits car. Defence doesn't apply as there must be a total loss of voluntary control |
| Bailey | Hypoglycaemic state was self-induced by failing to take food after a dose of insulin - defence fails |
| Hardie | D takes valium trying to calm down but becomes agitated, sets fire to a wardrobe. Valium is external factor and defence applies |
| Hill v Baxter | An example of an external factor is a driver being struck by a stone or attacked by a swarm of bees and swerving into traffic |