click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Criminal Law - GenD
General Defences: Self Defence
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Test for Self-Defence | D used reasonable force in circumstances as they genuinely believed them to be in defence of self, another, or property |
Dewar | Football dad - Force not used during attack - defence doesn't apply |
Harvey | Nose Biter - force necessary if pinned down, but not necessary otherwise |
Williams | You can rely on a genuine mistake |
O'Grady | You can't rely on a drunken mistake |
Oye | The test is subjective, therefore the force used on police is necessary (thought they were demons) |
Bird | Withdrawing or showing an unwillingness to fight is evidence that D is acting reasonably, but this is no requirement` |
McInnes | Went towards the trouble so self defence couldn't apply |
Buckley | Relative size is relevant to how much force is reasonable |
Clegg | Car drives towards soldier - fires three shots. Final shot taken after the car had gone past so defence failed (excessive force) |
Beckford | Pre-emptive strikes are valid where there is genuine belief of danger |
Martin | Evidence showed that intruders were leaving when he shot them, so defence faile d - force used was unreasonable |
What type of defence is self-defence? | Full defence |
Palmer | Force must merely be necessary/reasonable - "D needn't weighto a nicety" - a range of responses are reasonable |
Rashford | D was agressor initially, but V and friends responded out of proportion to agression, so defence was successful |