click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Judicial Precedent
Unit 1
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Stare decisis et non quieta movere | stand by the decided and do not unsettle the established |
Res judicata | the decision |
Ratio decidendi | legal reasons they used to get to their decision. forms precedent( R v R 1991, Rv Bentham 2005) |
Obiter dicta | things said "by the way", irrelavent ( R v Howe 1987, Hill v Baxter 1958) |
Dissenting judgements | minority judgments, minority of judges came to same decision but for different reasons |
What is judicial precedent? | the source of law where past decisions of the Judges create law fro future Judges to follow |
Binding precedent | when a decision is made that must be followed by all others in the future for similar cases even if they don't agree |
Persuasive precedent | Don't have to use it because: it was made by a lower court or another commonwealth country, its obiter dicta statements, its dissenting judgments. |
Reason for law reporting | 1535-1865 cases were reported by individuals who sold them to lawyers bu their accuracy varied from reporter to reporter |
Incorporated Council of Law Reporting | Set up in 1865 and controlled by courts, produces official law reports which are written by trained barristers |
R v Bentham | Robbery with fake gun which was his hand, arrested fro robbery and possession of an imitation firearm Judge said "one cannot posses something which is not separate + distinct from oneself" |
R v Howe | Forced to kill someone under duress, HoL decided that duress was not a defense to murder. Also said that it would not be a defense for attempted murder. |
Hill v Baxter | Fell asleep whilst driving and drove into people . Found guilty of not stopping when feeling drowsy. Gave fictional example of being stung by swarm of bees. |
What is original precedent? | Created when a Judge decides a case who's facts have never been seen before. This might mean looking for similar cases to get to the decision. |
Donoghue v Stevenson |