click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Assump & Loopholes
Assumptions & Loopholes
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Assumptions | conclusions are supposed to be proven by the premises; if a piece of the conclusion is not mentioned in the premises, chances are the premises aren't proving it 100% true (this is our gap between the premises & the conclusion) |
| Sufficient Assumption | proves the conclusion 100% true; powerful language |
| Necessary Assumption | if the conclusion is true, the necessary assumption must also be true; NAs are the foundation of the argument's house, basic, boring, & obvious |
| Assumption Chain | the sufficient assumption proves the conclusion & the conclusion proves the necessary assumption (guarding against devastating loopholes is the necessary assumption's job) |
| Loophole | the flip side of the necessary assumption (the negated version of the necessary assumptions); it is how you call the author out on their nonsense |
| Three Commandments of the Loophole | the Loophole shalt not negate the premises; the Loophole shalt not negate the conclusion; the Loophole is there & thou shalt figure it out |
| Dangling Variable | new words that appear in the conclusion & not in the premises (if the author does not do the work to connect the premises & the conclusion exactly right, you cannot automatically do it for them) |
| Secret Value Judgements | the author gets judgy in the conclusion (what if that value judgement doesn't have that definition?) |
| Secret Downsides | the author compares two things & says one of them is superior without giving you the full story (what if the argument's preferred option has a big downside?) |
| Assumed Universal Goals | things the author assumes everyone would want (what if they don't want to?) |