click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
NATEX#2Read1
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Who defines the nation as an imagined political community? | Benedict Anderson |
| What are Anderson's four features of the nation? | Imagined, limited, sovereign, and a community. |
| What does "imagined" mean for Anderson? | Members feel connected despite never knowing most fellow members personally. |
| Does "imagined" mean fake or imaginary for Anderson? | No. All large communities must be imagined because members cannot all know one another. |
| Why is the nation "limited" for Anderson? | Every nation has boundaries beyond which other nations exist. |
| Why is the nation "sovereign" for Anderson? | Nationalism arose as divinely ordained dynastic rule lost legitimacy. |
| Why does Anderson call the nation a "community"? | It is imagined as deep horizontal comradeship despite actual inequality. |
| What puzzle motivates Anderson? | Why nations inspire such deep attachment and sacrifice despite being historically constructed. |
| What kind of bond does Anderson emphasize most? | A subjective sense of fellowship among otherwise anonymous strangers. |
| What is the easiest memory cue for Anderson? | ANDERSON = IMAGINATION: strangers imagine themselves together. |
| Which author should you think of when you see "imagined community"? | Anderson. |
| Which author focuses most directly on how people mentally conceive a large community? | Anderson. |
| What older political forms does Anderson contrast with nationalism? | Religious communities and dynastic realms. |
| Why are nations historically unusual for Anderson? | They create fellowship among enormous numbers of strangers who never meet. |
| What famous Anderson idea explains nationalism's emotional force? | Horizontal comradeship among members of the imagined nation. |
| Who says nationalism is primarily a political principle? | Ernest Gellner. |
| What is Gellner's basic principle of nationalism? | The political unit and national unit should be congruent. |
| What is nationalist sentiment for Gellner? | Anger at violation of national-political congruence or satisfaction when it is fulfilled. |
| What is a nationalist movement for Gellner? | A movement motivated by nationalist sentiment. |
| Does Gellner think nations and states naturally belong together? | No. Their apparent congruence is historically contingent, not natural. |
| Can nations exist without states according to Gellner? | Yes. Nations and states are not the same thing and neither automatically produces the other. |
| What two provisional definitions of nation does Gellner discuss? | Shared culture and mutual recognition of one another as members of the same nation. |
| Why are Gellner's provisional definitions insufficient by themselves? | Culture and recognition become nationally important only under particular social conditions. |
| What major historical change drives nationalism for Gellner? | The transition to modern industrial society. |
| What does industrial society require culturally for Gellner? | Standardized communication, literacy, education, and a common high culture. |
| Why does industrialization increase the need for cultural standardization? | Mobile specialized workers must communicate and retrain across roles. |
| What role does mass education play for Gellner? | It reproduces the standardized high culture required by industrial society. |
| What is "high culture" in Gellner's argument? | A standardized literate culture transmitted through formal education. |
| How does agrarian society differ from industrial society for Gellner? | Agrarian society tolerates many local cultures; industrial society pushes toward standardized culture. |
| What happens to local "low cultures" under nationalism in Gellner's account? | They are often replaced or absorbed by a standardized high culture. |
| Does Gellner think preexisting nations create nationalism? | Usually no; nationalism often creates the nations it claims merely to awaken. |
| What does "nationalism engenders nations" mean? | Nationalism helps construct unified national cultures from previously diverse populations. |
| Does Gellner think nationalism invents culture from nothing? | No. It uses existing cultures but transforms, selects, and standardizes them. |
| What is Gellner's famous description of nationalism culturally? | The general imposition of a high culture on a society of previously diverse local cultures. |
| What institution should instantly remind you of Gellner? | The school system. |
| What is the easiest memory cue for Gellner? | GELLNER = GEARS: industrial society needs standardized educated workers. |
| Which author most strongly links nationalism to industrialization? | Gellner. |
| Which author argues that nationalism creates nations rather than merely awakening them? | Gellner. |
| Which author should you associate with high culture and standardized education? | Gellner. |
| What does Hechter say nationalism is above all? | Political. |
| How does Hechter define nationalism? | Collective action designed to make nation and governance-unit boundaries congruent. |
| Why does Hechter use "governance unit" rather than simply "state"? | Governance existed before modern states and can occur at several territorial levels. |
| What is a governance unit for Hechter? | The territorial unit providing most order and collective goods to its members. |
| What kinds of goods does a governance unit provide? | Order, justice, welfare, protection, and similar collective goods. |
| What does national self-determination mean in Hechter's framework? | Making the nation's political boundaries match its governance boundaries. |
| Can congruence be pursued inclusively for Hechter? | Yes. Diverse groups can be incorporated as equal members of the polity. |
| Can congruence be pursued exclusively for Hechter? | Yes. Membership can be restricted or groups expelled or destroyed. |
| Is nationalism always liberal or always illiberal for Hechter? | Neither. His definition includes both inclusive and exclusive nationalism. |
| Why does Hechter reject moral definitions of nationalism? | Definitions should be analytical rather than simply separate good nationalism from bad nationalism. |
| Does nationalist art or sentiment alone count as nationalism for Hechter? | No. There must be political collective action seeking national self-determination. |
| Is nationalism a constant or variable for Hechter? | A variable; movements can pursue sovereignty to different degrees. |
| How does Hechter distinguish nationalism from imperialism? | Empires can rule diverse peoples without trying to make them culturally homogeneous. |
| How does Hechter distinguish nationalism from regionalism? | Regionalism seeks rights or resources without necessarily seeking sovereignty. |
| What is the basic core of a nation for Hechter? | A relatively large group of unrelated people with high solidarity. |
| Does language automatically create a nation for Hechter? | No. Language may matter in some cases but does not automatically produce national solidarity. |
| Does religion automatically create a nation for Hechter? | No. Objective differences alone do not necessarily create nationhood. |
| What subjective element matters for nationhood in Hechter? | Shared awareness that differences distinguish one group from relevant others. |
| What objective feature does Hechter think nations require? | Territoriality or a real or putative homeland. |
| How does Hechter distinguish a nation from a general ethnic group? | A nation is a territorially concentrated ethnic group associated with a homeland. |
| What relationship does Hechter propose between nations and ethnic groups? | Nations are a subset of ethnic groups. |
| Why does territorial concentration matter politically for Hechter? | It makes sovereignty and independent statehood more realistically attainable. |
| What is state-building nationalism for Hechter? | Central rulers assimilate or incorporate culturally distinct territories into a homogeneous polity. |
| What is peripheral nationalism for Hechter? | A distinct territory resists incorporation or seeks secession and self-government. |
| What is irredentist nationalism for Hechter? | A state seeks adjacent territory inhabited mainly by its co-nationals. |
| What is unification nationalism for Hechter? | Politically divided but culturally similar territories seek merger into one state. |
| Does Hechter consider patriotism a form of nationalism? | No. Patriotism concerns state prestige when nation and governance boundaries are already congruent. |
| What is the easiest memory cue for Hechter? | HECHTER = BORDERS: nation boundary should match governance boundary. |
| Which author should you think of when you see "governance unit"? | Hechter. |
| Which author emphasizes territorial concentration and homeland most explicitly? | Hechter. |
| Which author gives state-building, peripheral, irredentist, and unification types? | Hechter. |
| What idea do Gellner and Hechter share about nationalism? | Both emphasize congruence between national and political boundaries. |
| What separates Gellner from Hechter despite their shared congruence idea? | Gellner explains modern nationalism through industrial culture; Hechter defines and classifies political nationalism. |
| What separates Anderson from Gellner most clearly? | Anderson stresses imagined fellowship; Gellner stresses industrial standardization. |
| What separates Anderson from Hechter most clearly? | Anderson explains imagined belonging; Hechter emphasizes political action and territorial governance. |
| Which author asks how strangers can feel like one people? | Anderson. |
| Which author asks why modern society needs shared standardized culture? | Gellner. |
| Which author asks how nation and governance boundaries become politically aligned? | Hechter. |
| Which author is most associated with subjective imagination? | Anderson. |
| Which author is most associated with industrial society? | Gellner. |
| Which author is most associated with governance and territorial boundaries? | Hechter. |
| What three-word memory chain separates the authors? | Anderson = Imagine; Gellner = Industrialize; Hechter = Govern. |
| What image can help distinguish Anderson? | Picture millions of strangers imagining the same national community. |
| What image can help distinguish Gellner? | Picture a factory feeding into a standardized national school system. |
| What image can help distinguish Hechter? | Picture two maps whose national and governance borders are being made to match. |
| If a question mentions print-mediated imagined fellowship, which author is closest? | Anderson. |
| If a question mentions schools creating standardized high culture, which author is closest? | Gellner. |
| If a question mentions sovereignty, territoriality, and governance units, which author is closest? | Hechter. |
| Do all three treat nations as timeless natural entities? | No. All reject a simple primordial view of nations as naturally fixed and eternal. |
| What broad issue unites all three readings? | How large national communities are defined, constructed, and politically organized. |