click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Science 403
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Hicks argues | that scientific debates are often narrow, and only represent the views of technical experts. The broader social context in which the issue is situated is often ignored. Debates often become polarized. |
| Why study controversies? | Increasing occurrence, politicization of science, scientization of policy (and society), pace of scientific, technological, environmental, and social change |
| Conventional View-science is | a systematic method and a collection of facts, formulas, and theories. Good science is objective |
| Conventional view-good science is objective | Observer-independent reality. Science is separate from personal and social contexts. Technology is applied science. Science and technology ensure human progress. |
| Alternative view: science is social | All knowledge is situated in social contexts. Science actively constructs ideas about and relations to the natural world. Science and technology are intertwined. |
| All knowledge is situated in social contexts | many approaches, theory-laden, value-laden |
| Alternative view: science is social, part 2 | The products and processes of science can have unintended consequences, producing both benefits and problems for society |
| Social contract | means an unwritten agreement about how procedures and practices will be conducted. It informs what we think of as acceptable practices and behaviour |
| For most of the 20th century | universities, government research establishments and industrial laboratories operated independently from public scrutiny. Quality of scientific work evaluated internally by scientific/ expert peer communities |
| For most of the 20th century, who produced knowledge? | Scientists produced knowledge. Citizens expected to give up their rights and responsibilities to professionals in exchange for the benefits science and technology provide. |
| Manhattan project and development of atomic bomb | 1942-1945. Goal was to end WWII. Harnessed fission for military purposes. International project. Robert Oppenheimer tested the bomb. August 6, 1945 dropped little boy on Hiroshema and fat man dropped on Nagasaki |
| 1960-1970 | Period of social ferment and questioning of authority. Rise of new social movements: environmental, peace, feminist, civil rights, anti-nuclear |
| Big science | Large scale projects that require significant investment from state governments. Homan genome project and particle accelerators are examples. |
| 1970 and beyond, Orientation of research towards profit | value of science increasingly measured by profitability to national economy, corporate competitiveness, military preparedness. Innovation, technology-focused research is given more emphasis. Science replaced by technology? |
| Greater role for civil society | Reorient research agendas, question the direction that dominant research is taking, create new knowledge and new practices |
| Implications of new social contract | scientists and engineers engage with social issues (ethics, politics). Citizens learn to deal with science, technology, evidence, and uncertainty |
| Disagreements are | inherent to science and democracy |