click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Sugya 16-17
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| According to the פסוק, what happened in the morning? | The בני ישׂראל gathered the מן |
| According to the פסוק, what happened after the morning ended? | The sun got hot and melted the מן |
| Does the תורה tell us any specific time for these events? | No |
| The מכילתא said that "וחם השמש ונמס" was during which hour of the day? | 4th hour of the day |
| From what time to what time is the 4th hour of the day? | 9:00 - 10:00 |
| The מכילתא said that "כחם היום" was during which hour of the day? | 6th hour of the day |
| According to the מכילתא, the morning ended at? | 9:00 |
| The sun then melted the מן from what time to what time? | 9:00 - 10:00 |
| This מכילתא seemingly cannot be the חכמים because according to the מכילתא, morning ended at what time? | 9:00 |
| But according to the חכמים, morning ends at? | 12:00 |
| This מכילתא seemingly cannot be ר' יהודה because according to the מכילתא, morning ended at what time? | 9:00 |
| But according to the ר' יהודה, morning ends at? | 10:00 |
| The מכילתא CAN be the חכמים even though morning ends at? | 12:00 |
| The entire morning cann be spilt into 2 parts. Early morning is from what time to what time? | 6:00 - 9:00 |
| Late morning is from what time to what time? | 9:00 - 12:00 |
| The מכילתא CAN be ר' יהודה, even though morning ends at? | 10:00 |
| The בני ישׂראל finished collecting the מן by 9:00, this was how many hours before the morning ended? | 1 hour |
| What does “בבקר בבקר” teach me according to the חכמים? | Divide the entire mornig into 2 parts |
| What does “בבקר בבקר” teach me according to ר' יהודה? | The בני ישׂראל finished gathering the מן 1 hour before morning ended |
| Why does “וחם השמש” imply the 4th hour of the day? | It is a time when the sunny areas are hot and the shady areas are cool |
| Why does “כחם היום” imply the 6th hour of the day? | Because then the heat of the day is felt even in the shady areas |